Ihsan

Tuesday, March 29, 2005

Why Do They Hate Us This Month?

Here are some of the facts from this month which might (or might not) help Americans in answering the ever-vexing question, "Why do they hate us?" You be the judge.

· Despite the awareness of widespread U.S. torture of detainees in Iraq being pretty commonplace, a soldier who tried to report the torture of detainees was found to be “insane” by his commanding officer and forced against his will to leave Iraq for “rehabilitation.” Seems reminiscent of other societies and how they dealt with their “social deviants” and others who would speak up, doesn’t it?


· Torture has been now described as “one of the most important secret weapons in the war on terror” and therefore “extraordinary rendition,” or basically the outsourcing of torture to countries where inconveniences such as the illegality of torture and the affirmation of due process and civil liberties are either non-existent or simply irrelevant, is totally justified. The only difficulty we’re having is getting the right people “rendered”…apparently, a lot of folks have been sent to the gulags “by mistake.”

· A 45-day jail sentence, as well as $12,000 in docked pay, was what Army 1st Lt. Jack Saville received after he pled guilty to “having two Iraqis thrown at gunpoint into the Tigris in Samarra,” one of the two Iraqis known to have died. After his indictment, Saville stated that he would have preferred “non-judicial” punishment and that his actions made him concerned about “putting fellow troops in increased danger by inciting insurgent Iraqis, who portrayed the incidents as war crimes.” Who says that military men don’t care about people, their dignity, and their lives? And throwing prisoners into the river and killing them is considered war crimes…how the Iraqis employ such devious propaganda!

· Paul Wolfowitz, neo-con architect of the Iraq war and supporter of “shock and awe” treatment for the recalcitrant Iraqis, has been nominated by Pres. Bush to the presidency of the World Bank. It seems as if the worldwide uproar over the World Bank/IMF Washington Consensus that enforces a disastrous neoliberal agenda on the world’s governments and peoples has made Bush realize there needs to be a change. Instead of neoliberal-led development, we shall now have the “neocon” version. Perhaps “shock and awe” may be the way to eliminate global poverty as well…

· The list of known prisoner deaths under the U.S. custody in Afghanistan and Iraq seems to be expanding on a daily basis. Army and Navy investigators have definitively concluded that at least 26 prisoners have died in possible cases of criminal homicides, with a total of 108 deaths under American custody. The utter lack of transparency at many of these sites in Iraq and Afghanistan will guarantee that the number of unknown Afghan and Iraqi prisoners killed remains, well, unknown. And the latest news is that the 17 G.I.’s implicated in some of these prisoners’ deaths will not be tried by the Pentagon. Lest the skeptics out there forget, this is an important reminder about how our President is determined to “bring justice to them,” i.e. the wrongdoers (at least the darker-skinned and foreign-looking ones, and whether they’ve done anything wrong is irrelevant).

· More and more details emerge of Iraqi prisoner abuse by American soldiers. One of the more sordid revelations was that the prisoners in Abu Ghraib and elsewhere have included children. One incident reveals that in order to “break” an Iraqi general, his child was tortured right in front of his eyes. And we have known that the U.S. has had a policy of detaining and torturing women and children related to men who they suspect are involved in the resistance in Iraq. And most recently, we learn of video footage of U.S. military abuse of prisoners at Guantanamo that may parallel that of the horror of Abu Ghraib. Torture of children, new Abu Ghraibs…thank God we have an independent and vigilant U.S. media which focuses on these things. If you’ve missed this stuff, you must be reading or watching foreign, biased media or something!

· Some claim that neo-liberalism and the Washington Consensus has the power to eliminate poverty as-we-know-it. The Indian government has succumbed to this belief. In order to comply with World Trade Organization requirements, India will halt its production of affordable generic drugs, drugs which save the lives of literally millions of AIDS patients throughout the world. Neo-liberalism must have the answer as to how destitute, seriously ill patients will now afford the prohibitively expensive drugs offered by the Western pharmaceutical companies…we’re just not looking hard enough for the answer.

· World Water Day was celebrated in March. The World Health Organization estimates that over 1.1 billion people have no safe water and 2.4 billion have no sanitation, leading to over 3 million deaths per year. Who are the idiots that claim that safe drinking water and a healthy living environment are universal human rights!

· The Israel-Palestine situation, that one, no two, no three thousand (God knows how long that problem has been going on) year old conflict has produced some “interesting” statistics this month. According to the Bank of Israel, the Arab poverty rate is triple the Jewish rate: 46.2% of Arab households lived in poverty in 2003, compared with 14.6% of Jewish households. From the Palestinian Central Statistical Bureau we learn that 3,861 Palestinian women lost a son or daughter in the four years of the Intifada and 66 Palestinian women were forced to give birth at Israeli checkpoints, resulting in 38 deaths. And finally, we learn of the blasphemy committed by an IDF officer who admits to the Israeli newspaper Ha’aretz that Israeli settlers actually commit violent acts against Palestinians…perhaps the treatment meted out to that strange American soldier accusing his colleagues of torture and abuse can apply here, too: call this guy “insane” and send him for rehabilitation and re-education.

· From “civilized” and liberal, human rights- and minority-friendly Europe we get a report from the National Consultative Commission on Human Rights which states that 1,565 threats and acts of violence against mainly Muslim and Jewish victims were registered in 2004, compared with 833 the previous year. Progress, indeed.

· In the Congo, we learn of the high price Congolese must pay to noble U.N. peacekeepers attempting to bring peace and civilization to constant inter-tribal warfare in Africa: offer their daughters’ bodies for sex, and if their lucky, receive a buck in return from the thoughtful peacekeepers.

· Finally, there is the story of the Algerian woman Hassiba Belbachir. She was leaving the United States, was detained and brought “into custody” in Chicago. A couple of days later, she is “found” dead and officials claim she committed suicide. Others who know how American prisons and detention centers in the U.S. and in other countries (do Iraq, Afghanistan, Guantanamo Bay ring a bell?) operate suspect a different story in this situation. How many Abu Ghraibs and Hassiba Belbachirs will it take to make us outraged and sleepless at these horrors? But that’s why we have Jerry Springer and Fox News right, so that we can have a good night sleep?

“Why do they hate us?” An absurd question, isn’t it, after seeing all of these facts documenting our benevolence?

6 comment(s):

  • Please provide documentation for your accusations. I see a lot of absurd charges being thrown about with no links from credible (i.e., non-Muslim) news sources. Without CREDIBLE sources all you are doing is inciting those who want to believe the worst (without proof). Play smart, play nice. Use some brains. DOCUMENT. I may have problems with militant, radical, fundamentalist Islam (and I do), but I will NEVER resort to throwing around baseless accusations without being able to document my posts.

    By Blogger Conchobar9258, at 3/30/2005 03:44:00 AM  

  • Salaams

    Let me get this straight. You are saying that the credibility of these stories depends on verification from non-Muslim sources, because any Muslim source is ipso facto suspect. I see.

    The assumption, then, is that the American media (which is non-Muslim) is - at least in some sections, reliable. Oh dear!

    May I refer you to a closely referenced and detailed rebuttal of the latter thesis: Edward S Herman and Noam Chomsky (1994) 'Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media' (Virago).

    If you need any contemporary verification of the Herman/Chomsky thesis, I refer you to the US-media coverage of Israel/Palestine. Laugh? I nearly did.

    Wasalaam

    Yakoub


    By Blogger Julaybib, at 3/30/2005 04:03:00 AM  

  • Ironically, almost all of the facts I've listed come straight from the U.S. press, AP reports, Washington Post, etc. If you need the specific source for any one of these facts (and believe me, they are all "non-Muslim"--therefore credible, right?--sources), let me know.

    By Blogger Abu Dharr, at 3/30/2005 09:22:00 AM  

  • conchobar9258-

    Just for the sake of it, here you go:

    the sentencing of lt jack saville: http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/breaking_news/11143645.htm

    Over 300 stories on Wolfowitz and the World Bank via google news: http://tinyurl.com/4s4g3

    On prisoner deaths in US custody, there's sources in many places, but here are a few, some with names, as I believe knowing the name of the person killed may just bring it HOME to those who should feel their humanity:

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/worldlatest/story/0,1280,-4870390,00.html

    And one of how various soliders are not being prosecuted for unlawful deaths in both Iraq and Afghanistan: http://www.startribune.com/stories/484/5313864.html

    (other stories about it elsewhere, too)

    Here's the 108 number, if you're looking for it:
    http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/paperchase/2005/03/us-military-ups-possible-number-of.php

    India and generic drugs: http://tinyurl.com/4o8jw

    Arab poverty rate stats:
    http://www.globes.co.il/serveen/globes/docview.asp?did=896946&fid=942

    and also at the Jerusalem post: http://tinyurl.com/5egtn

    threats in europe: http://www.guardian.co.uk/france/story/0,11882,1443206,00.html

    Congo sources at bloomburg: http://tinyurl.com/3qnjg
    and BBC news: http://tinyurl.com/44lm4
    and the Independant: http://tinyurl.com/3l8ym

    the Hasiba BelBashir story- well documented, by various name spellings in the news. here is one search via google news:

    http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8&filter=0&q=Hassiba+Belbachir&btnG=Search+News


    By Blogger Leila M., at 3/31/2005 06:51:00 AM  

  • no idea if he'll come back to the site, so I posted it in his own blog's comments section as well...

    By Blogger Leila M., at 3/31/2005 06:53:00 AM  

  • thanks for this, leila.

    By Blogger Abu Dharr, at 3/31/2005 08:58:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home